Reclaiming Hard Work: The danger of labels (even positive ones)

6212121217 2d621ddd6c Reclaiming Hard Work: The danger of labels (even positive ones)

Andrew Carnegie, Pittencrieff Park

Estimated read time: Article 4-7 minutes
Estimated read time: Attachments and sources 3.5 - 6 hours

What has Hard Work become?

Hard Work is concept so ingrained within the lexicon that it's easy to be recursive: hard work is... hard work. In America, we love to identify with the hard working loner, the pioneers and the innovators. Names like Ford, Carnegie, and Rockefeller conjure images of success and innovation... in addition to cool hats and 3-piece suits. Perhaps it's the romanticism of this ideal that has allowed politicians and power-seekers to co-opt the term....

Much of today's divisive rhetoric is devoted to championing the 'hardworking' citizen. And it's always 'our' team that’s hard working. Those other guys? They're lazy.

This is a dangerous concept.

Linguistic Labels

7565320434 20fae22a26 Reclaiming Hard Work: The danger of labels (even positive ones)

Gary Lupyan at Carnegie Mellon University, along with colleagues at Stanford and the Center for Neural Bias of Cognition, have done some interesting work on how verbal labels impact mental associations and characterization. (Download Language is not Just for Talking here)

Learning nonsense verbal labels facilitated categorization more than did learning nonverbal associations. - G. Lupyan, et. al.

Basically, labels give us an easier way to file something away in our mental libraries. We come to faster conclusions, incorporate information sooner, and retain it better... because we assess this new information much, much less.

Labels also make information 'stickier'. There is also some evidence that categories learned with labels were more robust than those learned without labels. - G. Lupyan, et. al.

We hold onto our labels and cast aside the explanation because someone else has done the heavy mental lifting for us. All we have to know is that X and Y are connected, not how or why they are. And this is fine. In fact, our brains have evolved to process information like this because it's efficient.

However, when this process is turned inward, it is often subjected to the above-average effect.


 

Reclassification

827213443 8b51afa0b3 Reclaiming Hard Work: The danger of labels (even positive ones)

People are prone to fallacies of composition and confirmation bias: we jump to irrational conclusions that tell us what we want to believe. So, when others tell us over and over again that we're hard working... we believe them. In fact, we believe a lot of great things about ourselves.

So when Elizabeth Warren, who has said a lot of intelligent things, says:

I'm here tonight to talk about hard-working people: people who get up early, stay up late, cook dinner and help out with homework; people who can be counted on to help their kids, their parents, their neighbors, and the lady down the street whose car broke down...

She's doing more harm than good.

In 2001, a little-recognized paper was published in the journal Cognition. In it, Robert L. Goldstone and his colleagues detail how new labels can alter perception, and new perceptions lead to a change in behavior. (Download Altering object representations through category learning here)

By a Changed Object Description account, category learning alters the description of the objects themselves, emphasizing properties that are relevant for categorization. - R.L. Goldstone, et. al.

And therein lays the danger of unearned labels. A rose by any other name may still be a rose, but call something a rose long enough and people will believe it's a rose.

464046403 6583bc82d1 Reclaiming Hard Work: The danger of labels (even positive ones)

Man, I love roses.

Believing that a tulip is actually a rose isn't that different than believing the lives we live day-to-day are typically involve hard work. Both are simple miss-characterizations. The difference is that one misunderstanding could get you in a fight with your spouse, and the other can sabotage every goal you ever set for your entire life.


 

Hard work defined

In order to recapture hard work, we need to cast off the watered-down expectation that what most of us do on a daily basis is hard.

Hard work is about risk. It begins when you deal with the things you would rather not deal with: fear of failure, fear of standing out, fear of rejection. Hard work is about training yourself to leap over this barrier, tunnel under that barrier, drive through the other barrier and after you’ve done that, to do it again the next day. - Seth Godin, Small Is the New Big Reclaiming Hard Work: The danger of labels (even positive ones)

Hard work involves sacrifice; sacrificing ego, time and comfort come with the territory  When you strain against your limits, when you push into new territory, when you expand who you used to be and give way to who you want to be... you're probably working hard. When you take leaps of faith and get back up when you fall, you're probably working hard.

Most of us want things in life, and few of us will be gifted with those things. Sure, some people get lucky, but Hard Work, determination, and perseverance are the common paths to achievement.

What was the last barrier you broke down?


Related posts

Additional reading

1 comments
Claudio
Claudio

it was an immeasurable pleasure to read your posts. i will definitely be coming back here.

Trackbacks